Finster Murphy's TM

1497 SE 17th St.
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316 (954)765-3461


10:00 am - 7:00 pm 

11:00 am - 4:00 pm

Christmas Eve
10am - 4pm

New Years Eve
10am - 5pm 

Memorial Day, 4th of July, Labor Day
11:00am to 4:00pm

Closed: Easter Sunday, Mothers & Fathers Day, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Day, New Years Day

Kitchen Hours:
11:30 am - 3:30 pm
4:30 pm - 6:30 pm 

11:30 am - 3:30 pm
(subject to change) 

Gooey Cookies

Gooey Cookies

Do you love gooey cookies? Gooey On The Inside is New York City’s premier cookie company. If you don’t live close, no problem, you can order online and have them delivered to your front door.

Why are Gooey On The Inside Cookies Special?

Our cookies were created in a small compact kitchen in New York City by a foodie who knew she could make the best cookie. She wanted a crisp on the outside side and chewy and gooey on the inside.  She made the best gooey cookies, and a company was born.

We love catering parties and are happy to help you choose from a variety of cookies, jars, cookie bites, and more. Gooey On The Inside will make catered deliveries to any address in New York City. Just give us a time, destination, and we will provide you with a delivery quote based on the time and distance and size of the order. The other options are a shipping quote, or you can pick your order up at our Lower Eastside kitchen for free. The choice is yours.

What Kinds of Cookies Do you Sell?

We have the following flavors available:


  • Cap’n Crunch Peanut Butter Choc Chip Chunk cookie has peanut butter chips, Cap’n Crunch cereal, dark chocolate chips, milk chocolate chips, dark chocolate chip chunks in a golden cookie.
  • Fluff That Think cookie is a yellow sponge cake cookie with cream and chocolate filling.
  • S’Mores cookie is a blend of French dark and milk chocolate with marshmallows and a golden cookie.
  • I’m Super Black cookie is a white chocolate cookie with a sweet cream filling with blackberries.
  • Red Velvet Cookie has white chocolate chunks and a sweet cream-cheese center.
  • Oatmeal Oh My! Is the best oatmeal cookie with caramel, banana, and milk chocolate chunks you can find anywhere.
  • Chocolate Chip Chunk cookies have dark, and milk chocolate chips and have dark chocolate chunks in a golden cookie.
  • Dunkaroo Cookie is loaded with white chocolate chips, a creamy vanilla icing with graham cracker crumbs and sprinkles.
  • Birthday Cake Cookie has imported French white chocolate chunks, colorful sprinkles, and a real birthday cake flavor.


We sell gooey cookies, but we also have what we call Goowees, which are cookie bites. They are available in the same flavors as our cookies. We also sell Molten Cookie & Soft Baked Cookie Dough in a Jar. We sell an 8 oz Molten Cookie Jar and a 16 oz. We also sell a Soft-Baked Cookie Dough Jar in an 8 oz size.  We have the same flavors as our cookies except for the PB & J S’mores.

How do you Ship?

We ship all our orders via the United States Postal Service. Our orders ship out only on Mondays. There are no exceptions, even for important events like Birthdays and Anniversaries. It takes about 5-7 days from when you place an order until we ship. USPS will not deliver our cookies to PO Boxes. No international shipping. We bake to order. We will send you a confirmation when your order ships. Cookies can be frozen upon arrival to ensure freshness. Try our gooey cookies today. 

Gooey on The Inside Cookies
+1 646-972-0409
Gooey Cookies
163 Chrystie Street
New York NY 10002

View Larger Map

We welcome your comments!